Vacation rentals in Cupids Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cupids Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Governor's Harbour

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Cayo Loco Villa for 2 On Deserted Pink Sand Beach!

S2E2 NETFLIX "WORLD'S MOST AMAZING VACATION RENTALS"! Beachfront villa right on deserted secluded pink sand beach! Watch dolphins with your coffee/coconut water/tarts! Beach toys included! Eleuthera means 'freedom'! Tranquil authentic tropical island paradise fusing eco design w/comfort! 1 of 2 brightly colored villas! Beach stroll to dining/bar/pool! Fish/surf/boat/dive/kayak/paddle board/relax! Unspoiled pristine oasis! 1 bed 1-1/2 bath 2 ADULTS ONLY! NO SMOKING/KIDS/LOUD MUSIC/VISITORS/FIRES!

Mar 7 – 14

$400 per night

Superhost

Home in Governor’s Harbour

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Welcome to Outer Reef, a slice of heaven on Earth.

Let the Atlantic Ocean take center stage at this newly renovated and centrally-located ocean front home. Designed specifically to highlight all the natural beauty that Eleuthera has to offer, and to sooth your soul into relaxation. With a bedroom with en-suite on either side of the house, make this a couples retreat, or keep the entire house to yourselves for that romantic getaway! Flat walkable beaches for miles, and swimmable Atlantic Ocean. WiFi, kayaks and snorkel equipment. Adults only!

Nov 16 – 23

$644 per night

Guest favorite

Home in Governor's Harbour

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Solar and Sea bungalow with StarLink Wi-Fi

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Private bungalow. Solar powered. The bungalow also has Satellite high speed internet A Bahamian laid back vibe styled bungalow on our hillside property with gardens. Breathtaking Carib sea views and sunsets. Swimming and snorkeling is a brief walk down the hill to the sea. The Atlantic Ocean and pink sand beaches are a 10 minute walk. We are located in the center of Eleuthera and the Settlement of Governors Harbour is a 10 minute drive.

Jan 17 – 24

$133 per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Governor's Harbour

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Classic Bahamas cottage / 60 second walk to ocean.

*Low $75 cleaning fee. No other host fees. *Superhosts since 2016. Over 1000 five star reviews on Airbnb alone. *Local Bahamian experience in a great location 3 miles from Governor's Harbor. *FREE snorkel gear, 2 person kayak, Stand Up Paddle board and grill. *AC, Wi-Fi, Smart TV, kitchen, walk in shower, totally renovated. *Owner rents discounted SUVs to guests. *Discounted tours for swimming pigs, snorkeling fishing, etc. *60 second walk to ocean with excellent snorkeling right from shore.

Feb 26 – Mar 5

$170 per night

Guest favorite

Bungalow in Governor's Harbour

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Centrally located 1 BR, 1 BA Cottage

Rose Manor Cottage is located "on the hill" in Governor's Harbour, Eleuthera, Bahamas. Walk almost anywhere in town from our centrally located property. The cottage comfortably sleeps two and has everything you need for a wonderful stay. Enjoy mangoes from our trees, relaxing on the balcony and taking in all that Eleuthera has to offer. A property manager is available to greet you upon your arrival, as well as answer any questions you may have about the house or the island during your stay.

Feb 15 – 22

$180 per night

Guest favorite

Home in Governor's Harbour

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Ocean Front Home, Banks Road, Governor’s Harbour

NEWLY REAPPOINTED for 2023- a beautiful ocean front cottage overlooking secluded Eleuthera cove in Governor’s Harbour close to Pascal’s and French Leave Beach. It is perfect for anyone seeking a peaceful getaway. All modern amenities - generator, A/C, Starlink satellite WIFI, 4K smart TV with AppleTV, propane gas BBQ, fully-equipped kitchen, Alexa, multiple decks overlooking the ocean and elegant styling. The cove is a snorkeler’s paradise and nearly always without any other beach goers

Feb 22 – Mar 1

$450 per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Rainbow Bay

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Li'l Mooncliffs - Your Special Caribbean Retreat

Newly renovated studio apartment conveniently located mid-island in the popular Rainbow Bay. The cottage is perched 60ft. on the cliffs overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. Less than 1/2 mile on the beautiful Caribbean side is Rainbow Bay Beach with clear, calm turquoise water suitable for swimming, snorkeling or just relaxing on the beach with a breathtaking view. Local grocery store approximately 1-1/2 mile away and plenty of local eateries further down Queens Highway in James Cistern.

Nov 23 – 30

$110 per night

Superhost

Home in Governor's Harbour

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

CupidsWay-New Home-Pool-Snorkel-Cliff Jump-Kayaks+

Perfectly located to see all of Eleuthera, less than 4 miles from the center of Governor's Harbour. This well appointed, modern waterfront home with a large designer pool sits on almost 200 linear feet of Caribbean frontage with incredible snorkeling, cliff jumping and beautiful day and night views of Cupid's Cay - the original Bahamian capital! 4 kayaks, a SUP and water toys are provided. Beautiful foliage, flowers, fruit and vegetable trees during season surround the property.

Sep 3 – 10

$396 per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Governor's Harbour

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Upstairs 1BR Bayfront Apartment w/ ALL Amenities!

Welcome to The Governor's Harbour Collection - Anchor Point Apartments; an affordable, condo-style development located in the heart of Governor's Harbour, Eleuthera. The complex is comprised of two buildings: One contains 2 one bedroom apartments and two standard two bedroom apartments, while the other building contains 2 larger, two bedroom apartment suites. All units are built with covered, outside balconies that offer fantastic views of Anchor Bay.

Aug 11 – 18

$170 per night

Guest favorite

Home in Governor's Harbour

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Welcome to Balara Blue!

Escape to a tranquil sanctuary perfect for the entire family, where cherished moments await. Welcome to Balara Blue, an exquisite family-oriented residence nestled along the serene shores of Balara Bay. The unrivaled location of this captivating abode ensures a remarkable stay, with the privilege of a private beach at your disposal each day. Unwind, recharge, and forge unforgettable memories with loved ones on the captivating island of Eleuthera.

Jun 27 – Jul 4

$574 per night

Superhost

Cottage in North Palmetto Point

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Cottage on private pink sand beachfront property

Our 5 cozy single bedroom cottages are conveniently located in Central Eleuthera on one of its most stunning pinks sand beaches surrounded by a garden filled with local plants and adjacent to a boutique Hotel with restaurant, bar and pool. Groups of up to 10 people please contact us to book multiple cottages, or you can book them one-by-one here on Airbnb. All cottages are identical in layout, and size. Discounts offered for stays +7nights.

Oct 1 – 6

$262 per night

Guest favorite

Home in Central Eleuthera

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Beach please! Home on Ten Bay beach w/generator

No Rush @ Sea Dreams is a beachfront tropical paradise for guests seeking romance, privacy, tranquility and adventure. Sunbathe, snorkel, paddle board and kayak from your private beach. Watch sunsets from the seaside palapa, and watch shooting stars on the expansive deck at night. The open concept, modern decor and new appliances include a well-appointed kitchen, plush linen and a generator.

Sep 8 – 15

$319 per night